Differences in culture: Comparing our personal views to previous research

Introduction

In this blog we will try to showcase the differences between Dutch and U.S. culture, and the culture shocks that can occur when one moves from the Netherlands to the U.S.

We are lucky we have the perfect anecdotal proof from one of us, since Bart moved to the U.S. two months ago from the Netherlands for an exchange semester.

We will look at multiple forms of differences between culture in communications, that are described in the book written by Kory Floyd (2011). Firstly we will describe our general view of the differences, and then we will look at Hofstede’s model, and compare our experiences to his research.

Our general view of the differences.

In general, we found out of our experiences that American culture is more extreme in a couple of ways. The believes in the U.S. are often very strong, which we attribute for a large part to the individuality and that children are taught from young age to voice their opinion. These values and norms can either be religious, political, or for example on feminism or capitalism. In general the Netherlands are not very religious, and we are generally taught as children to “act normal”. A prime example of this would be a political campaign poster in the Netherlands.

”Getting the Netherlands out of the financial crisis”—Very normal (filled in), not normal (blank)—Acting. In a Normal manner. VVD (Name of the political party).

This very much describes the dutch, one should not act out to much but just act normal.

Hofstede’s model:

We will use Hofstede’s model for cultural differences, since it’s one of the most used and well respected models to define differences in culture. We will look at the data from Hofstede Insights (2019), and compare it to our personal experiences. We will look at 4 dimensions, that are described in the book by Floyd (2011): Individualism/Collectivism, Low/High-context Cultures, Low/High-Power Distance and Masculinity/Femininity.

Blue=The Netherlands, Purple=The United States

(Hofstede Insights, 2019)

Individualism/Collectivism:

Brooke’s View: Americans are Individualistic; American celebrate being different from one another and this is shown from a young age, almost every child has been told they are special for being themselves. Americans always want to be different from one another in some way and most noticeable in how they dress. It’s very normal for Americana to have dyed hair, piercings, tattoos, and to dress in such colorful or unique ways. Women will wear much bolder styles of makeup in America than in other countries. Americans celebrate being different because that’s what we were taught.

Bart’s View: Dutch people aren’t exactly collectivistic, they still find personal success and well-being very important. However the way they achieve it is often through superior educational results, and not with their appearance. A lot of Dutch people look alike, which is also partly because there are less different races and people in the Netherlands, it is predominantly white. In the recent years more and more Dutch people have started dressing differently and trying to look different, but in general the consensus is still: “be normal”.

Comparing our Views to the data:

As we saw in Brooke’s view, the data supports the high level of Individualism. Bart’s perception of Individualism is a little bit more towards the collectivism side, even though he still says it is more individualistic. The difference in Bart’s view and the data might be explained by the fact that people, even though they are told to be normal and fit in, still hold personal success and results to a high regard.

Low and High-Context Cultures:

Brooke’s View: In general the American culture is low-context, in which people say directly what they want to say. However, many women are very blunt with each other. Especially, when mothers and daughters are dress shopping. At first moms will say things such as maybe try a different dress but once the daughter has tried on the third dress then moms will say everything that’s wrong with the dress and to go get something else instead. Americans won’t be upfront right away but will get to this point quickly.   

Bart’s View: The Dutch culture might be one of the lowest-context cultures in a way. For example: if someone gets a gift they already have, they will tell the person if they can get the receipt so they can bring it back to the store and get something else. This is something that wouldn’t happen as quickly in the U.S.

Comparing our Views to the data: The graph we found doesn’t mention Low and High-context cultures. Other research has shown that both America and the Netherlands are Low-context countries though, which is similar to our view on it. From Bart’s view we may possible conclude through further research that the Dutch culture might even be a little more direct and Low-context than the American culture.

Low and High Power-Distance Cultures:

Brooke’s View: In general, the hierarchy in the U.S. is decently prevalent. If someone is your direct superior, you will question them at times, but their ideas will always go through and most people are okay with that. In the workplace in most American jobs there is only one or two bosses and all the rest of the workers are equals. In my workplace I can joke and challenge one of my bosses because we are more friendly with each other but with the other boss I never question anything and just do as I’m told. So, there is a hierarchy but it can shift and change depending on the people.     

Bart’s View: In the Netherlands people have learned that everyone is equal and ideas from people lower in the chain are often appreciated more. There of course is still a little bit of a power distance, but it is lower than in the U.S. in my opinion. Personally, I work in a small company (2 superiors and 3 interns) in which I can mostly voice my opinion openly, even towards the superiors. My view might we a little bit biased though, since I’ve worked in mostly jobs that require a higher education. In lower education the power distance might be larger and more prevalent in the Netherlands.

Comparing our Views to the data: Our views steer off from the main data quite a bit. In Brooke’s view, the American hierarchy is decently prevalent. We would maybe expect it to be higher than 50 then, however it is only 40. The differences in the middle of the graph (40-60) might be more negligible though, since they all come up in the middle of the spectrum. Surprisingly Bart’s View of the power distance is quite a bit lower than the real power distance (38). This might be because, as he said himself, he might be biased and it might be different in higher education jobs.

Masculine and Feminine Cultures:

Brooke’s View: The U.S. is quite a masculine culture, focusing a lot on competing, individual success and hard work to get to that point. America also is a lot more unfair to women. There is a lot of sexism in American still with unequal pay and harassment. I believe the U.S. is a masculine culture because we are also a high power culture. Men are perceived to be more dominant while women are not. This can directly affect women and men in American culture.        

Bart’s View: The Netherlands are more feminine, they focus more on the quality of life. This can be clearly seen in the amount of hours people work in both countries. In a study by OECD (2017) it can be seen that American workers work an average of 1780 hours a year, in comparison to 1433 in the Netherlands. In general, the U.S. is one of the countries that works the most, and the Netherlands one of the countries that works the least. This attributes to the fact that the Netherlands is a country with higher femininity; a lot of people work less hours to spend 1 day with their children for example. Personally, I also prefer to work in teams instead of individual performance, which is also a sign of more feminine culture.

Comparing our Views to the data:

Brooke’s view came back quite the same way the data also came back. The U.S. general has a reasonably masculine culture. Bart’s view also compared decently to the data, in which we could see the Netherlands is quite a feminine country, which influences both quality of life, work hour and communication decisions they make.            

Conclusively:

Our views came out mostly the same way the data was set up. In some instances there was a little bit of a gap, which as we said before might be because of personal biases or the personal experiences that we have had in life. This was definitely a subject that was interesting for us to study, since we are both interested in learning about different cultures, and the way communication works in those cultures.

References

Floyd, K. (2011). Interpersonal Communication. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Hofstede Insights. (2019). http://www.Hofstede-Insights.com. Retrieved from Hofstede-Insights: https://www.hofstede-insights.com/country-comparison/the-netherlands,the-usa/

OECD. (2017). http://www.Stats.OECD.org. Retrieved from Stats.OECD: https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=ANHRS

How to Spot a Liar with Nonverbal Communication

Nonverbal Communication and Lying

Background of Nonverbal Communication

“Nonverbal communication can be described as behaviors or characteristics that convey meaning without the use of words,” (Floyd, K. 2011). Nonverbal communication is not however sign language since that is the use of words but not sounds. Nonverbal communication is intrinsic for all humans but varies in meaning from culture to culture, however, nonverbal communication is usually used more to understand meaning than verbal communication across the board (Floyd, K. 2011). People believe nonverbal communication over verbal communication because it’s much harder to control nonverbal communication. Anyone can say they had a great day but if they sign and roll their eyes and have a lot of tension in their voice, then this can be much harder to control. Your words convey that you had a great day but your nonverbal communication says you’ve had an awful day. People could become better at understanding liars by examining their nonverbal communication. People also can tell a lie very easily from nonverbal communication. People who are bad at lying will become tense, nervous, dry mouth, sweat a lot, and have stiff posture (Floyd, K. 2011). But there is more to lying than just this.

Pop Culture of Finding a Liar

Every BuzzFeed and Cosmopolitan article will try to tell you how to spot whether or not your significant other is lying to you by exaggerated and misleading explanations. Of course these articles will focus on things such as having a partner that won’t let them have a look at their phone right away, and them being vague about what they are doing or where they are going at a given time. These things will probably not catch a good liar and might have something more to do with the other person having bad communication skills and not being nice to them. However, there is no clear-cut Pinocchio effect with people who do lie. If people’s noses grew every time they told a lie, life would be perfectly easy to stop people from lying; except when your significant other asks you if that dress makes them look fat.

Why Do We Lie?

People lie for many reasons. We lie to help people, let children believe in Santa, to not hurt someone’s feelings, or to get something we want. Bhattacharjee from National Geographics  stated: “Our capacity for dishonesty is as fundamental to us as our need to trust others, which ironically makes us terrible at detecting lies (2017).” We all lie because it’s what we have done since the dawn of time but we still need to trust others even when we lie so much ourselves. It is a common saying that people lie three times in about ten minutes. These lies Range from white lies about the tooth fairy to serious lies about for example infidelity or theft.

  The table shows the type of lies are told and how frequently they are told by percentages.   

Lying and Nonverbal Communication

As bad as most humans are at detecting lies, there are plenty of ways to spot when a person is lying, whether they think they are a good liar or a bad liar. Now finally the point of this blog: How to tell through nonverbal communication if someone is lying to you.

Firstly every person is different. A stranger could be lying to you and you’d be known the wiser. When someone you know better, such as a friend however, tells you a lie it can be easier to pick up on. The reason for this is that you have set up a baseline, the way a person normally acts.

The key to finding their lies is when they deviate from this baseline, and act abnormally. For example a friend that usually doesn’t make eye contact a whole lot starts making a lot of eye contact. This change of behavior can be very noticable and vise versa when they make eye contact and then don’t. Eyes are very important to nonverbal communication and can explain a good amount of what is needed to know. However, this is not the only way to detect lying through nonverbal communication.

People will do many things to try and hide that they are lying to people. However, they will also give red flags that will show they are lying. Since lying triggers the fight or flight response, and the stress that accompanies this, people will clear their throats. The reason for this is that when people lie their throat goes dry from stress and the moisture that was once in the throat is now turned to sweat. Because of the sudden loss of moisture in the throat the liar will have to hard swallow causing a jump in the Adam’s apple. Liars will also manipulate their jaw. They will move their jaw forward and backwards slightly to active the salvation glands, again to gain moisture. An eye movement that liars will use is eye pointing. They will have their eyes dart to exits, either psychical exits or “technological exits”. Such a technological exit will be that the liar will look at their phone, watch. Another way of recognizing liars is them wanting to cut conversations short because they want to leave the physical stress they are under. They will both point their eyes and their feet to exits so they can flee much easier.

Liars will also lean their heads backwards. This is a sign of distancing themselves from anxiety. People will lean forwards when they like a person or a situation but then will lean their head back when they dislike someone. Along with a head being leaned backwards people will also sway their bodies backwards or lean back against something. Lastly, people will want to protect their Suprasternal Notch. This is the base of the neck, one of the most vulnerable places on a person’s body. People will rub the back of their neck or if they are wearing a necklace they will pull and tug at it as a way of protecting it. These are a few ways to tell if a person could be lying to you (Schafer, 2014) .

However, These are not sure fire ways. As said in the earlier paragraph the best way to tell if a person is lying is noticing any big changes in their behavior. In the first paragraph we went over the fact that people will trust nonverbal communication much more than verbal communication, so it’s definitely good to learn more about these signs. When a person looks for either physical or technological exits this also very much signals this person wants to leave because they are lying even if they say they are telling the truth.    

https://www.nbcnews.com/better/video/how-to-tell-if-someone-is-lying-to-you-1024397891586

References

Morris, R., & BHATTACHARJEE, Y. (2017, June 05). Why We Lie: The Science Behind Our Deceptive Ways. Retrieved from https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2017/06/lying-hoax-false-fibs-science/

Schafer, J. (2014, November 4). 9 Red Flags That You May Be Talking to a Liar. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/let-their-words-do-the-talking/201411/9-subtle-signs-someones-lying-you

Steinhilber, B. (2017, August 15). 5 signs someone’s lying to you. Retrieved from https://www.nbcnews.com/better/health/how-tell-if-someone-lying-according-behavioral-experts-ncna786326

Exploring a new concept: “The Dark Side of Image Management”

Image Management, or the process of projecting one’s desired public image (Floyd, 2011), is a concept that every person utilizes. Many people use image management to seem credible, trustworthy or a nice person. But there might also be a dark side to image management, and that is what we want to explore in this blog post.

In research in the past, for example the article on rating depression by Hamilton (1960), the following variables are taken into account:

These variables don’t really take the image depressed people carry out into account, the hiding of their true feelings. This is “the dark side of image management” we want to address in this blog.

Floyd (2011) described three fundamental principles of image management; It’s collaborative nature, the fact we manage multiple identities and the complex nature of image management. We will also project these three principles in the case videos we found.

The first video we will watch is a video about depression in 1959: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GIwl3eQhSGI&bpctr=1551985513.

In this video we see three different patients, one young woman, one older woman and one older man.

The first patient, the young woman, speaks about not being able to face things in life. At 1:27, the psychiatrist asks: “You have told me the other day that you have always made plenty effort, not to show that you’re depressed, have you always made it a point to kind of—cover up and suppress your feelings?”

Young woman: “Yes.”

Psychiatrist: “Why?”

Young woman: “Well, I guess that is just part of me. When I was quite young, for a time I went to a stage where I was a real monster. I tried to get my mother’s attention, which I couldn’t get. I would break things and cry and throw tantrums and it didn’t do any good. And then I realized that my aunts and the people could see how hurt I was and I didn’t want anyone to see. To be able to tell that I was hurt, so I tried to make it opposite, I tried to make it seem like I didn’t care about anything. And it worked, people believed that I didn’t care.”

It is clear this young woman struggled a lot with “the dark side” of image management. Her true feelings were a lack of attention from her mother and being hurt by this lack of attention. At first she says she behaved like a monster. This however, is the image she gives herself for that period of time, while other people could also see a hurt child that is acting out for attention. However, her mother probably treated her as “a monster”, which is why she also described it as such. This is a glaring example of image management being collaborative.

Later, when she tried to act like she didn’t care, the collaborative nature of image management came out again, other people believed she didn’t care, contributing to her keeping the same behavior intact. She very much disliked being “a monster” afterwards though, saying it could make her aunts and other people see how hurt she was. This exemplifies that image management is complex, and she is trying to find different ways to not show her emotions.

The second woman, the older one, is clearly trying to keep up an image of not being depressed while being in the interview.

Psychiatrist: “What about when you thought about going to the basement and getting rid of yourself?”

Older Woman: *Smiling*” I can’t remember thinking about that.”

This shows another part of “the dark side” of image management: the fact that people suppress their feelings to a point they will start to believe their new image and do anything to deny their real feelings. These feelings are stowed away and are not being handled, which leads to heavy emotional strain.

The third person, the aged man, although being honest with the psychiatrist, would still tell jokes to keep up his image, even though he couldn’t be cheered up by anything.

Psychiatrist: “There was nothing that you could enjoy?”

Older man: “Absolutely nothing, there was no one I could see, that I would be glad to see, there was nothing anybody could say that would cheer me. Although, as I said before, I could still tell a joke, even then I could tell a joke.

Psychiatrist: “And make other people laugh?”

Older Man: “Yes, and I think the reason for that is, is that I had always been known to be a joker and enjoyed the fact that people enjoyed me telling them jokes. It would give them a good impression of me. I would muster up the strength of a story so somebody would notice me. Some of the nurses really would enjoy how well I could tell a story. Other nurses however, told me to take the long look off my face. One nurse I particular, who I didn’t think really belonged there. Because I was sitting there, my face must have been a mile long, and she more or less criticized me for it. She said: there is nothing wrong with you, what are you looking so glum about. And I have believed that, I have believed that she was right. There was nothing wrong with me, all I had to do was be a man and snap out of it. And It made me feel worse. ”

This man has a great way with words. He quite clearly states, without even being aware of it, the fact that he is dealing with multiple identities. He truly feels depressed, but to keep the identity of being a joker intact, he still tells jokes. Here we also see his true intention, to be noticed by people. Both with the first lady and with this man we see what turned them to “the dark side” of image management, a lack of interpersonal communication, and wanting to be noticed.

I would describe the concept I explored here: “the dark side of image management”, as hiding one’s true pain to create an image in which this pain is less visible.

Another example, which is very similar to the older man in the previous case, would be Robin Williams. At 2:35 in the following video, Robin Williams speak about his image: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fm0isCG1aBM.

Announcer: “Williams suffered manic depression”.

Williams: You know, no, I’m not always fun to be around. And that there is this thing of yeah, the world sees one thing, and what am I like at home, something different, because I can’t always be on.”

Williams clearly struggled with managing multiple identities and with “the dark side” of image management, namely hiding his depression by telling jokes and being jolly.

Conclusively, this blog went over some cases of a self-defined principle: “the dark side of image management”.

In most of these cases, this principle comes about because of a lack of attention and the feeling of being hurt by that. A lot of these cases are people that are just wanting to be noticed by the people in their life.

“The dark side of image management” can show itself in different ways in one’s image. One can create a not-caring image, one can start believing in their own image, even though they suppress their feelings, or one can hold on to a joker image, because that is one of their identities. There isn’t much literature to be found on this topic, so we are hoping this blog post might spark discussion leading to further research into this topic.

Cited Works:

Floyd, K. (2011). Interpersonal Communication. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Hamilton, M. (1960). A rating scale for depression. Department of Psychiatry.

A etnographic space review of the Cathedral of Learning

We decided to do our ethnographic spaces blog on the Cathedral of learning ground floor. This building is the second highest university building in the U.S.. The ground floor is 2000 m2. The main tenant is the University of Pittsburgh, that has both classrooms and offices in the building. Other tenants are Starbucks and Chick-fil-a. The first day we went there was on the 12th of March, on a tuesday between 4:00 and 6:00 pm. The second day we went there was on the 15th of March, on a friday between 9:00 and 11:00 am.

We set up a timelapse and created a timelapse video, so we could create a very clear and detailed image of the exact flows of people walking in and out of the cathedral, and those that were sitting down.  Unfortunately these videos couldn’t be uploaded to our blog, since they were of a wrong file type. For that reason we will describe the flow. We went to the building on two separate occasions, to get a better grasp on the flow within the building on different days and on different times. We first went on a wednesday in the afternoon, expecting a more busy day and time in the cathedral. The second time we went on a friday in the morning, expecting it to be less crowded. When we came in on wednesday there were already some groups of people sitting down and studying, and there were a lot of people walking up and down the aisle to get to other places. On friday however, we were the first ones in the cathedral. There were still some people that came in early too and started working there, but this was a very marginal amount. Another thing we noted was that on friday morning there was a class of children that had a tour through the building and the nationality rooms. This also gave a different feel for the flow through the building.

Another thing we noted was the fact that there seemed to be more security in the building. Our guess is that they increase security in the weekends to better handle the people and to prevent vandalism in the building. There were still no security checks at the main entrance though.

In general we concluded the following from our observations:

That there is more flow of people getting to a point of destination through the cathedral on wednesday in the afternoon than there is on friday, where there were few people, and most of them sat down instead of walking through. On friday there was a class of children doing a tour though.

The security seemed more present and present in higher number while on friday in the morning, in comparison to wednesday in the afternoon.

We also completed the interior review checklist, and gave our argumentation for every choice we made.

Management

58. Tenant agencies program events in the interior public spaces: +2. The university of Pittsburgh runs multiple events for their students and faculty members.

59. Programmed events are well promoted and consistently well run: +2. Through facebook pages and student run organisations, the University of Pittsburgh promotes their events well.

60. The public sometimes requests to use the ground floor for events: +1. It is an option for the public, however it rarely happens that a non University of Pittsburgh members tries to run an event in the cathedral.

61. Interior public spaces are clean and free of clutter: +2. The building is well maintained and very clean for an old space. There are also garbage cans to throw away the trash in.

62. Management provides a welcoming presence inside the building: -2. None of the University of Pittsburgh staff are at the first floor. The only thing greeting people coming in is a banner of Pitt.

63. There are interior spaces that can be used for outside groups and organisations: +2. Anyone can sit within the first floor and study or look at the building.

Total: 7

Design

64. The lobby is open and inviting: +1. The lobby is open but seems very serious, because of the age and stature of the building. This makes the place not the most inviting to sit down when you are not there for studying, but inviting to look around.

65. There are comfortable places to sit and wait in the lobby: +1. There are definitely enough places to sit, and there are chairs and benches all around. However, the furniture is made out of wood, making it more uncomfortable to sit here in long spans of time.

66. Services such as ATM’s and delivery services drop-boxes are unobtrusive, easily accessed, and consolidated where possible. 0. There is an ATM in the cathedral, however it is not on the first floor, so this isn’t applicable.

67. Informal meetings often take place in the lobby: +2. People often come to the cathedral to hang out and talk with friends. This is accommodated by the University of Pittsburgh by having events, such as emotional support dog events.

68. Lighting throughout the building is appropriate and highlights special features: +2. The lighting definitely fits the style of the building and the lighting highlights the tables and the corner features of the building, making it a feat to look at.

69. The layout of the lobby supports its use for a range of activities: +2. You have a good walkway with multiple exits and entry points. A big space in the middle, and more confined spaces on the sides, creating more privacy.

70. The building includes spaces for public meetings and events: +2. The first floor can be rented out to anyone, and public events sometimes take place.

71. There is retail amenities in the lobby (such as shopping, food service, post office, etc.): +1. There is a nationality shop for people to buy souvenirs for the different nationality rooms. We disregarded the “before/after security” part since there isn’t any security checkpoint.

Total: 11

Security:

There isn’t a major security checkpoint in this building, and there are only a few guards around. There are security cameras though, but the building isn’t very secure. We would say the building would score negatively on security, since there are now checks and people with bad intentions could walk right into the building. In our conclusion we will come back on this, but it wouldn’t make sense to score the building on this criterium since there is no security checkpoint, and a lot of the questions are out security checkpoints.

Images and Aesthetics:

86. Information about the building and its namesake is provided in the lobby: +1. There aren’t many signs, there is one but it is only the trustees. In the shop in the lobby, some information can also be learned about the building and they have multiple folders about the different rooms in the building.

87. Information about tenant agencies and what they do is clearly communicated in the lobby: -2. There isn’t any information about the Starbucks or Chick-fil-a in the building and some people only know that there are classes in the nationality rooms. The top floors, with University of Pittsburgh staff, isn’t highlighted at all.

88. Public art or exhibits are presented in the lobby: -1. There is no public art or exhibits in the lobby. However, to bring a little nuance into the conversation, there are nationality rooms around the first floor that do have art of that nationality in them. The public art is well-maintained, however since it isn’t in the lobby we won’t give it a score.

90. Signage is uniform throughout the lobby and presented in consolidated locations: -1. There are signs and they are all the same size, but they are not in the lobby, they are only closer to the exit points and the elevators.

91. Permanent finishes are high-quality and in good conditions: +2. Everything is really well maintained, the fireplace and carvings are very well maintains and there are very few flaws and very little vandalisation to the property.

92. Lobby furnishes are consistent and reinforce the character of the building: +2. The wooden chairs and the lighting creates the character of the building, it tries to replicate the cathedral feel of the room.

93. Portraits and Plaques are hung in an orderly fashion: +2. The banner and the one plaque of the trustees are very structured and hung in a very orderly fashion.

94. Government literature, handouts and information are well-presented and organized: 0. There aren’t any government related writings in this building.

95. Secondary elements such as trash cans and recycling bins, are not obstrusive: +2. Trash cans are put out of sight, they are located near big pillars, and in this way are available to people but not in the way of people.

96. Visitors and tenants get a positive impression of the federal government from the lobby: 0. Not applicable, there are no federal government related agencies in the building.

Total: 5

Access and Circulation:

97. The lobby connects to the primary exterior public space: +2. Through multiple entries from the main side of the building and from all different sides (north, east, south, west), to get to this floor.

98. Signs, maps and other wayfinding devices are easily understood by visitors to all tenant agencies: -1. There are signs that tell the floor certain tenants are on, however there are no signs on the specific floor about what staff is where.

99. Visitors can quickly locate tenant agencies through the lobby: -1. There is a sign, however it is by the elevator, and not in the lobby itself.

100. Elevators and stairs are labeled so they can be easily found: +1. They are labeled and can be found, however the signs for the stairs are very small, so not very easily found.

101. Signage and information is removed as soon as it is out of date: 0. All the information and signs that can be found are permanent, so this item is not applicable.

Total: 1

The total of all the items together is:

Management: 7

Design: 11

Security: -10. Not applicable, the security is very minimal, however the building does not feel unsafe. For people visiting Pittsburgh however, this building might feel more unsafe. We will take of 10 points to balance out the fact that a lot of the security isn’t really there and thus not applicable. In this way we hope to still be able to use this metric close to its intended purpose.

Images and Aesthetics: 5

Access and Circulation: 1

Total: 14 points

Conclusively:

The design and the aesthetic of the Cathedral of learning is quite appealing and makes it quite a good public space. The access and circulation could be better, especially with the signage in the middle room, but the building is still accessible from all different sides of the street. There is security in the Cathedral, however there is no security checkpoint, making it impossible to fill in most of the security questions. It is definitely a point that might make it a bit of a worse public space, however from our personal experience, it doesn’t feel very unsafe.